Withings ScanWatch 2 vs Amazfit Zepp E Square: The No-GPS Smartwatch Segment
Both the Withings ScanWatch 2 and Amazfit Zepp E Square deliberately skip GPS, targeting buyers who care more about design and everyday health tracking than sports performance metrics, at a $49 price gap.
The ScanWatch 2 looks like a traditional analog watch with real hands, hiding an ECG sensor and a 30-day battery life behind a small status display.
Global reference price
The Zepp E Square is a slim, fashion-forward AMOLED smartwatch, prioritizing screen quality and design over sports features.
Global reference price
Specification Comparison
Key Differences
The ScanWatch 2's analog design and 30-day battery life make it nearly indistinguishable from a normal watch at a glance — a real advantage for anyone who dislikes the look of a typical smartwatch screen. The Zepp E Square instead commits to a full AMOLED display, sacrificing battery life (7 days) for a more conventional smartwatch look and feel with richer visual notifications.
Pros & Cons
Withings ScanWatch 2 (42mm)
Pros
- Genuinely disguised as an analog watch
- 30-day battery life
- ECG sensor
Cons
- Small, limited digital display
Amazfit Zepp E Square
Pros
- Full AMOLED display for richer notifications
- Slim, fashion-forward design
Cons
- Much shorter 7-day battery life
- Higher price
Which One Is Right For You?
- Withings ScanWatch 2 (42mm): Best for buyers who want health tracking without looking like they're wearing a smartwatch at all.
- Amazfit Zepp E Square: Best for buyers who want a full-color smartwatch display but still don't need GPS or sports tracking.
Conclusion
Both intentionally skip GPS for the same reason — sports performance isn't the target use case — but they arrive at very different designs to serve that non-athlete audience.
Summary
Withings ScanWatch 2 (42mm)
Strengths
- Disguised analog design, exceptional battery life
Weaknesses
- Limited display
Amazfit Zepp E Square
Strengths
- Full AMOLED display
Weaknesses
- Much shorter battery life, higher price
For the most battery life and a genuinely disguised smartwatch, choose the ScanWatch 2; for a richer full-color display experience, choose the Zepp E Square.