Xiaomi Watch S4 vs Garmin Vivoactive 5
The Xiaomi Watch S4 and the Garmin Vivoactive 5 are priced $90 apart — $209.99 versus $299.99 — close enough that the choice between them comes down to features, not budget.
The Xiaomi Watch S4 offers a 1.43" display, 15 days of typical battery life, built-in GPS.
Global reference price
The Garmin Vivoactive 5 brings a 1.2" display, 11 days of typical battery life, built-in GPS, 5ATM water resistance to the table.
Global reference price
Specification Comparison
Key Differences
The Xiaomi Watch S4 lasts noticeably longer between charges — 15 days versus 11 — which matters most for multi-day trips or anyone who dislikes daily charging routines. Screen size also favors the Xiaomi Watch S4, at 1.43" versus the Garmin Vivoactive 5's 1.2", making it easier to read notifications and metrics at a glance.
Pros & Cons
Xiaomi Watch S4
Pros
- Much longer battery life (15 days)
- Larger 1.43" display
- Lower price
- Built-in GPS
Cons
- No significant weakness versus the alternative at this price
Garmin Vivoactive 5
Pros
- Built-in GPS
Cons
- Shorter battery life (11 days)
- Smaller 1.2" display
- Costs a bit more
Which One Is Right For You?
- Xiaomi Watch S4: A good fit for buyers who wants to charge as infrequently as possible, prefers a larger, easier-to-read display and wants to spend a little less.
- Garmin Vivoactive 5: Makes the most sense for anyone who prefers Garmin's ecosystem and design.
Conclusion
Neither watch is a strict downgrade from the other — each wins on a different practical dimension, so the right pick depends on which of those matters more day to day.
Summary
Xiaomi Watch S4
Strengths
- Much longer battery life (15 days)
- Larger 1.43" display
- Lower price
- Built-in GPS
Weaknesses
- No significant weakness versus the alternative at this price
Garmin Vivoactive 5
Strengths
- Built-in GPS
Weaknesses
- Shorter battery life (11 days)
- Smaller 1.2" display
- Costs a bit more
There's no universal winner here — match the pick to whichever tradeoff (battery life, screen, or connectivity) actually applies to daily use.